One brand, one choice, three answers: $2,830, $2,625, and nothing at all. The nothing appears on three cars, for two completely different reasons.
Subaru is also one of the last places in this market where the question can be asked. Five of its thirty-nine variants come with a manual gearbox, and all five are in those two cars.
The arithmetic is ours. Subaru publishes a price for each variant and a feature list beside it. It does not publish what an automatic costs on each grade, which of its own prices belong to two different cars, or how many of its cars can still be bought with three pedals. We worked those out, and checked every figure with a script before writing a word of this.
One limit, and it belongs to a single row rather than to the method. Four of the five manual and automatic pairs below are equipped close enough to compare. The fifth, at the top of the WRX range, is not, and the section on it says so rather than counting it as a free gearbox.
What an automatic costs
| Grade | Manual | Automatic | The automatic costs |
|---|---|---|---|
| BRZ Coupe S | $52,936 | $52,936 | nothing |
| BRZ Coupe tS | $56,716 | $56,716 | nothing |
| WRX AWD | $54,086 | $56,916 | $2,830 |
| WRX AWD RS | $59,856 | $62,481 | $2,625 |
| WRX AWD tS | $68,256 | $68,256 | nothing, but see below |
Three distinct figures for one decision, inside one brand, on cars sold from the same showroom on the same day.
The $2,830 is the one to carry around, because it is the entry to the WRX range and it is the cleanest comparison in the table. The $2,625 above it is $205 less for the same change, which is not a pattern, just two prices set separately.
The BRZ pair
On the BRZ, Subaru's own page offers the range as two tabs, "Manual" and "Automatic", on identically named grades. We read both feature lists in full.
The two are the same list, item for item, apart from the gearbox. Both the manual and the automatic S list the 2.4 litre Boxer engine, 18 inch alloys, EyeSight driver assist and Subaru's Vision Assist. Both tS variants list the STI tuned suspension and Brembo brakes front and rear. The automatic's list adds one line the manual's does not, "Manual mode", which is the paddle override.
So on a BRZ the automatic is genuinely free: same car, same kit, same money, and the gearbox is a preference rather than a purchase. That is worth saying out loud because it is the opposite of what the same choice costs almost everywhere else. On the Mazda MX-5, the automatic costs $8,150 more than the manual once you price it drive-away, which is nearly three times the gap Subaru asks on the WRX and infinitely more than it asks on the BRZ.
The $2,830 WRX
Here is the part that makes the WRX figure sting slightly more than the number suggests.
| WRX AWD, base grade | Manual, $54,086 | Automatic, $56,916 |
|---|---|---|
| Gearbox | 6 speed manual | Sport Lineartronic |
| EyeSight driver assist | listed | listed |
| 18 inch alloy wheels | listed | listed |
| Cloth seat trim | listed | listed |
| Leather steering wheel with WRX logo | listed | not listed |
Everything else on those two lists is identical, down to the 11.6 inch centre display and the driver monitoring system. The one difference besides the gearbox runs the wrong way: the cheaper car is the one with the leather steering wheel.
We are reporting what Subaru publishes, not what arrives at the dealership, and a bullet point missing from a web page is not proof that a part is missing from a car. But it is Subaru's own list, it is the list a buyer reads, and on it the dearer car has one fewer item.
Where $0 is not free
The two dearest WRX sedans are both $68,256. The manual is the tS Spec B and the automatic is the tS Sport Lineartronic, and they are not the same car with a different gearbox.
| At $68,256 | tS Spec B, manual | tS Sport Lineartronic |
|---|---|---|
| Brakes | Gold Brembo, front and rear | not listed |
| Wheels | 19 inch matte grey | 18 inch |
| Rear spoiler | large rear spoiler | not listed |
| Equipment base | listed on its own | builds on WRX AWD RS |
That last row is the one that matters. Subaru's page for the automatic opens with "Features build upon WRX AWD RS Sport Lineartronic", so it inherits everything on the RS, while the Spec B's list stands alone and names the track hardware instead. Two genuinely different cars, deliberately priced at one figure.
So the honest reading of the table higher up is that the automatic costs $2,830 on the WRX, $2,625 one grade up, and at the top the question stops being about gearboxes and becomes a choice between Brembos and a sunroof. Anybody who reads that $0 as a free automatic has been handed the wrong answer by a price list that is technically correct.
Five cars in thirty-nine
| Subaru's range | Count |
|---|---|
| Nameplates on sale | 9 |
| Variants priced | 39 |
| Variants with a manual | 5 |
| Nameplates offering a manual | 2 |
The two are the BRZ and the WRX. Every Forester, Outback, Crosstrek, Impreza, Solterra, Trailseeker and Uncharted is automatic only, and so is the WRX Sportswagon.
That last one is worth a line, because the wagon is the WRX bodystyle a family would shortlist and it removes the choice entirely. The tS Sportswagon is $70,146 against the tS sedan automatic's $68,256, so the longer roof is $1,890. Skoda is the other brand still selling the same car two ways, and across five pairs there the wagon body costs either $2,000 or $1,000 depending on the grade.
Two prices, two cars each
| Price | One car | The other | So the choice is |
|---|---|---|---|
| $51,771 | Forester AWD Hybrid | Forester AWD Premium | the hybrid, or the extra equipment |
| $48,941 | Crosstrek AWD Sport | Crosstrek AWD 2.0S | the Sport look, or the 2.0S kit |
Both of those are a tie inside one nameplate, which is the useful kind: money comes out of the comparison and you are left choosing between two cars.
The Forester row says something plainer than it looks. At $51,771 Subaru's hybrid costs the same as the Premium, so on that rung the hybrid is free if you were buying a Premium anyway. One rung up it is not: the Hybrid Sport is $60,696 against the petrol Sport's $53,871, a gap of $6,825 for the same electrification.
And a cross-nameplate figure that catches people out: the dearest Crosstrek, the Hybrid S at $52,926, costs $1,155 more than the Forester AWD Hybrid at $51,771. The smaller car is the dearer car, as long as you shop to the top of its range.
What to do about it
On a BRZ, pick the gearbox you want. It is the same price and, on Subaru's own lists, the same car. There is no reason to compromise.
On a WRX, budget $2,830 for the automatic at the base grade. It is $2,625 at the RS. Those are two separately set prices, so get the one for the grade you are actually buying.
Do not read the $68,256 tie as a free automatic. The manual at that price has gold Brembos, 19 inch wheels and a rear spoiler; the automatic inherits the RS equipment instead. Ask for both feature lists on paper and choose the car, not the gearbox.
Ask what the leather steering wheel situation is on a WRX automatic. Subaru's list for the manual names it and the list for the automatic does not. It may well be there. It is a fair question to put to the salesperson in writing.
Get the price for your own postcode. Every figure here is Subaru's Sydney number, and Subaru's own footnote says it changes with location. The size of that change is not small and not consistent: we have found the cheapest city for a car moves with the car, by up to $3,360.
If you want a manual, ask early. Five variants in a thirty-nine car range means dealer stock is the constraint rather than the order form, and the WRX Sportswagon cannot be had with one at any price.
Sources
- Subaru Australia, BRZ, https://www.subaru.com.au/brz: the Manual and Automatic range comparisons, the four variant prices and the full feature list for each, read 8 November 2026.
- Subaru Australia, WRX, https://www.subaru.com.au/wrx: the Sedan and Sportswagon range comparisons, all eight variant prices and the full feature list for each, read 8 November 2026.
- Subaru Australia, Forester, https://www.subaru.com.au/forester: seven variant prices, read 8 November 2026.
- Subaru Australia, Outback, https://www.subaru.com.au/outback: five variant prices, read 8 November 2026.
- Subaru Australia, Crosstrek, https://www.subaru.com.au/crosstrek: seven variant prices, read 8 November 2026.
- Subaru Australia, Impreza, https://www.subaru.com.au/impreza: two variant prices, read 8 November 2026.
- Subaru Australia, Solterra, Trailseeker and Uncharted model pages: six variant prices between them, read 8 November 2026.
- Subaru Australia, the Recommended Driveaway Price footnote, carried in the same wording on every model page listed above: that the figure is shown for Sydney, 2000 and may change based on location, read 8 November 2026.
- Our own arithmetic: the five manual and automatic gaps; the $205 difference between the base and RS gaps; the $1,890 Sportswagon body gap; the $6,825 Forester Hybrid Sport gap; the $1,155 by which the dearest Crosstrek exceeds the Forester AWD Hybrid.
- Our own counting: thirty-nine priced variants across nine nameplates, five of them with a manual gearbox in two nameplates, and the two prices in the set carried by two variants each.
- Our own reading of Subaru's feature lists: that the BRZ pairs differ only by the gearbox and the automatic's added Manual mode; that the base WRX pair differs by the gearbox and the leather steering wheel with WRX logo; and that the two $68,256 tS variants differ by brakes, wheels, spoiler and equipment base.
- Elsewhere on this site: what an automatic Mazda MX-5 really costs, what Skoda charges for a wagon body, and why there is no cheapest city to buy a car.
We do not publish a discount figure. We will when we can measure one honestly, and not before.